home *** CD-ROM | disk | FTP | other *** search
- <text id=92TT0570>
- <title>
- Mar. 16, 1992: Doing It Right the Hard Way
- </title>
- <history>
- TIME--The Weekly Newsmagazine--1992
- Mar. 16, 1992 Jay Leno
- </history>
- <article>
- <source>Time Magazine</source>
- <hdr>
- CINEMA, Page 72
- Doing It Right the Hard Way
- </hdr><body>
- <p>The radiant Howards End caps 30 years of Merchant Ivory
- filmmaking: on the cheap, but with style
- </p>
- <p>By Richard Corliss--Reported by Dan Cray/Los Angeles
- </p>
- <p> Their company name, Merchant Ivory, is discreetly
- suggestive, like the first line of a haiku, or like their films.
- Merchant (Ismail, 55, Bombay-born): the getter, the peddler, the
- producer, the indefatigable fund raiser from private and
- government pockets in the U.S., Britain, India and Japan. Ivory
- (James, 63, Berkeley-born): the begetter, the director of films
- as smooth, durable, precious and endangered as an elephant's
- tusk.
- </p>
- <p> With novelist-screenwriter Ruth Prawer Jhabvala, 64--a
- German-born Polish Jew who escaped to England when she was 11,
- then lived in Delhi with her Indian architect husband for 25
- years until relocating in New York City in 1976--Merchant and
- Ivory form what amounts to a nuclear family, a multinational
- corporation and a tight little island of quality cinema. "We're
- like the government of the U.S. sometimes," notes Ivory as the
- trio sits in a suite at the Beverly Hills Hotel to discuss their
- new film, Howards End. "I'm the President, he's Congress, and
- she's the Supreme Court." The usually taciturn Prawer Jhabvala
- demurs, "They're more like Laurel and Hardy." Or the fabulous
- Baker boys, harmonizing from one dicey project to the next, with
- Prawer Jhabvala as their stern muse.
- </p>
- <p> They are also the industry's longest-running creative
- partnership; the Guinness Book of World Records says so. Thirty
- years ago this month, Ivory began shooting The Householder,
- which Merchant produced and Prawer Jhabvala scripted from her
- novel. Columbia Pictures bought the rights for a pleasant piece
- of change, and the company was launched. But not into the movie
- mainstream. "Someone else would have gone and made a house in
- the Bahamas and lived happily ever after," Merchant says. "But
- we didn't do that. We put the money into our next film." And so
- on and so on--dollar by rupee by pound sterling by yen--happily ever after.
- </p>
- <p> The triumvirate has collaborated on 15 films, many
- dramatizing the abrasion of English and Indian cultures:
- Shakespeare Wallah, The Guru, Autobiography of a Princess. But
- the best-known Merchant Ivory movies could be called
- Anglo-English: stately adaptations from Henry James (The
- Europeans, The Bostonians), Jean Rhys (Quartet) and E.M. Forster
- (A Room with a View and Maurice). With A Room with a View and
- their handsomely managed compression of two Evan Connell novels
- into Mr. and Mrs. Bridge (1990), the team found a fresh,
- elliptical vigor. Here were snapshots of family scenes that,
- when flipped briskly, revealed society in bittersweet autumnal
- splendor.
- </p>
- <p> Now Howards End, Forster's richest novel, has become
- Merchant Ivory's finest film. Elegant and powerful,
- accommodating collisions of class and temperament with the grace
- of a perfect Edwardian hostess, Howards End is the work to which
- all Merchant Ivory's other films have pointed and aspired.
- </p>
- <p> How modern, how very 1990s, the story of 1907 plays today.
- It is about real estate, and failing insurance companies, and
- the collision of feminism and domesticity, and the way the
- upper class misuses and misunderstands the masses. Howards End
- is a country home owned by the Wilcoxes, pompous Henry (Anthony
- Hopkins) and ethereal Ruth (Vanessa Redgrave), and visited, on
- crucial occasions, by the vivacious Schlegel sisters, Margaret
- (Emma Thompson) and Helen (Helena Bonham Carter). The
- friendship of Ruth and Margaret is the story's one pure and
- uncomplicated love. But the fulcrum is Leonard Bast (Samuel
- West), a clerk who dreams above his station, all the way to the
- stars. He will discover that the barriers of class are higher
- still, and that the playthings of the kind Schlegel sisters--their books and furnishings--can crush a working-class fellow
- who has unruly aspirations.
- </p>
- <p> A delight of nearly any Ivory film is the ensemble of
- actresses. In the lead, Thompson rises to the role's drama and
- fairly skates on its ironic wit. She also displays the requisite
- magic of a period heroine: by her radiant example, she teaches
- the audience how a beautiful soul might behave. Bonham Carter,
- who has appeared in four Forster-derived films, has never been
- so fetching a presence: her hair a wild nest, her features
- fiercely pre-Raphaelite. Redgrave is her usual revelation, this
- time as a lady cocooned in elevated frailties. So slowly,
- gently, gravely does she speak, she seems to be translating from
- a rarefied emotional language that cannot quite find its English
- equivalent. Yet she and the others are, variously, the ideal
- vessels to translate Forster's visions of femininity to the
- screen.
- </p>
- <p> Beginning with David Lean's A Passage to India in 1984,
- moviemakers have plundered five of Forster's six novels. It is
- odd that Forster, who lived into his 90s but wrote most of his
- fiction in his 20s, should have taken so long to become a
- cinematic cottage industry. But he was never one to make a
- strong early impression. Author Michael Holroyd has this nice
- description of the young novelist at Cambridge: "Of middle
- height and ivory pale complexion..."--we like the ivory;
- did destiny choose his skin color?--"he seemed to combine the
- bashful demureness of a spinster with the more abstract
- preoccupations of a don."
- </p>
- <p> This engaged reticence--the acutely tuned disinterest of
- an extraterrestrial observer who can be both amused and
- obsessed by the drawling brutality of English manners--informs
- all of Forster's novels. It also makes Forster an apt source
- for Merchant, Ivory and Prawer Jhabvala, three outsiders who
- have lavished so much attention on British propriety.
- </p>
- <p> Merchant Ivory films have often been admired, and reviled,
- for their dogged gentility, the Masterpiece theatricality of
- their style. Even the soggy films proceed at a confidently
- leisurely pace, as if Ivory realized that these days time is the
- dearest commodity; only he can afford it. Happily, the breadth
- of Howards End allows Ivory to indulge his visual whims--the
- riot of landscape, the open-air intimacy of a punt on a sylvan
- stream--while forcing him and Prawer Jhabvala to hone every
- scene ruthlessly, to find economy in gesture. You get the sense
- of an entire novel, its characters and character, unfolding in
- 140 minutes. Over the years, Prawer Jhabvala says modestly,
- "I've gotten better at fitting scenes together, at moving the
- action along. It's been a 30-year learning process, which is not
- finished yet."
- </p>
- <p> They will keep working and learning on a slew of
- tantalizing projects: adaptations of Prawer Jhabvala's novel
- Three Continents and Thomas Keneally's The Playmaker; perhaps
- an original, Jefferson in Paris, about the U.S. President when
- he was ambassador to France. They will keep making films the
- hard way, as a boutique operation surrounded by huge
- conglomerates. (Howards End cost a niggardly $8 million.)
- Merchant describes the process: "You put up the money for the
- option, get the screenplay written, get the costs down. You
- raise money for each particular stage as you go along. Yet you
- retain the rights. You're working for yourself."
- </p>
- <p> And sometimes, as with Howards End, you may have a hit.
- "Any film that succeeds is a major surprise," notes Ivory. "You
- have to lie down for a while."
- </p>
- <p> "No," counters Merchant, Laurel to his partner's Hardy,
- "you have to lie down."
- </p>
-
- </body></article>
- </text>
-
-